This photo, as a sitll life, isn't particularly well executed. It's lacking sharpness. When shooting a still life where you have total control over the environment, there is not much room for error. I can only guess at this, but based on the settings you posted and the lens choice you used, I'm assuming that you didn't use a tripod. That probalby contributed to the softness of the image. It does look like camera shake.
As for meeting the challenge, I think it's marginal. Everything in your image is indicative of a wider time frame when viewed by most. Meeting the challenge in a specific way is always the best route.
Great image. I like the lighting and the focus is excellent. The subject matter of each item in themselves is interesting but I think there is too much going on in the image. The interest of the guitar and stones ticket seems to be competing for attention with the alcohol and the smoke curls (which I'm not sure if its just me but it seems to have a bit of a skull look in it). Still a great interpretation of the challenge. I gave a 6
Okay, first of all, you NEVER lose the T-shirt, they are with you for life, I know, got several of them myself, LOL!
Good idea overall, nice concept, good execution on the idea, though the JW is a bit overpowered by the guitar and to me they should be on a more equal basis. Also the smoke could mean several things, hehehe :) Nice colors, good lighting overall, a 7