Author Thread
Post actions
Lovely work!! Great job on your top 10 finish!! You deserve it!!
Post actions
This was my top pick for country life. Great finish but deserved higher. Lovely timeless photo. Congrats.
Post actions
What a lovely image that projects the spirit of the country so well. Congratulations on your top ten finish.
Post actions
Beautiful (dreamlike), Jean. Congratulations.
Post actions
Great image. Congratulations on your top 10 finish.
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Post actions
I'd prefer this 100% b&w or 100% color. I like the photo, but not the selective desat.
Post actions
Beautiful photo. I love the selective desaturation job that you have done on this one, the subtle colours work really well. Nice composition and interesting subject. 10
Post actions
love the selective desaturation and the smiles ont their faces.
Post actions
Post actions
Great take on this and love how they all seem to be interacting with the photographer. I'm just not sure if the desat really adds to it.
Post actions
ack, a beautiful picture tainted by that cheesy selective desaturation effect.
Post actions
Wow, you got all 10 of my points!! :)
Post actions
Very emotive shot and nicely composed.
Post actions
Post actions
beautiful, really can't fault this picture, the compassionate desaturation, the depth of field and the composition are spot on.
Post actions
The concept is interesting, but the image is not realistic: the people look too happy for such back breatking work. I like the black and white.
Post actions
This is a wonderful photo! What I love so much about this is how happy those laborers look. I think of all the times I've whined and complained sitting behind my desk in my air conditioned office. . yet, these women look so full of life. This is just awesome!!
Post actions
nice desat...nice shot and true to challenge
Post actions
Enjoy the subtlety you used to bring out the worker in the front. Fits the challenge well.
Post actions
This is a very nice depiction, but I'd have preferred the whole thing in color, or at least all the people in color. Still, good response to the challenge.
Post actions
Beautiful shot and the selective chroma works very well her. 10
Post actions
I wonder why you choose to keep color in only one of the women.
Post actions
Post actions
Dreamy look to this. Well done.
Post actions
I like the selective desaturation, but I think I would have kept the people in the back in color, just like the woman. I would also place her right in the middle. The way it is now, my eye gravitated towards the blurry people because they are smiling.
Post actions
Nice shot though I don't understand your use of selective desat in this context... Great soft focus.
Post actions
Wonderful!!!!! I like the softness and their kind smiles!!!
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
