It is obvious here this was not panning, had there been panning the woman would be blurry. This is a great picture though, more of a Motion shot with the train swishing by.
As the subject is not moving this doesn't really fit in to the challenge description, I like the image though and the shadow of the lady on the train really adds to the photo, if she was standing even closer I think it would make it better.
Good choice of a moving object. I really like that the object is moving and she is standing still, it really makes you wonder why she is standing there.
I like this image, but it doesn't fit the challenge I think. The challenge was to focus on the moving subject and bring it out sharp on the foreground. In your image, the moving subject is blurry.
I do not think you met the challenge. It apears that the the only motion is the sped of the train pasing a very in focus lady. If the lady would have ben walking along the ramp and the train moving in the background, then the photo may have met the challenge. Best of everything
This is cool - it definitely gives the feeling of confinement and movement ... but you may get some "dnmc" - it appears that the train is moving, not the camera.
Nice blur, but no panning involved. As a photo in general, I like this, and would have liked it even better if the white balance had been properly adjusted to avoid the yellow cast.
Great pic. Does this meet the challenge though? I'm not sure if motion panning mean the photographer has to move the camera or the object can move. Oh well, I'm giving an 8 for this because it's a cool pic anyway!!