3 - Looks like good potential. Criticism; needs to be bigger (640 width in this case). Difficult to discern the clarity and sharpness focal wise, but looks like it may need to be sharper. Compositionally, I think if this were more off-centered, or even a vertical framing perhaps, make this better in my opinion.
This is a great picture, but I'm just afraid that this will be voted down because of the size, you should use the 640 pixels that we are allowed to use in challenges.
It's a little small. I'd like to see a bigger image, so I can see more detail I think this is probably an excellent capture, just too small to see a lot of the details.
This image is definitely strong enough to deserve being presented in a larger size. The overly small size detracts from the very real merits of the image.