excellent comp, excellent dof, great light, blacks not bad, whites need a small tweek, great texture, great flow, nice lines, overall could be a masterful b&w.
this image has real potential, but I find the ocean takes too much of the image so the eye has to look around to find something to focus on. the castle or whatever that house is should be lower in the image, I think id would help with the composition.
but I still like the image, but this is a tough challenge so only a 5 this time...