Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Post actions
impressive--but tree is getting silhouetted
Post actions
I can just barely make some detail on the trunk. Good thing too, cuz I would have deducted one point for being a silhouette.
Post actions
Very stimulating. Direct shadow shot. BW is good. DOF is good.
Post actions
Post actions
Great photo. I don't know much, but I think this is just about perfect.
Post actions
This is fantastic, good work
Post actions
great b&w,the perspective is really nice, but could it be that you burned the upper branches
Post actions
Post actions
Really like this in the black and white
Post actions
this is real "enhancing". Good photo.
Post actions
There is drama in this picture. I love the contrast and I am surprised how well the B & W works. 9.
Post actions
Another one that I nearly missed. The image is quite magical with the light from the sun behind the tree.....
Post actions
Lovely portrait of this tree. The halo of lighting that follows the major branches makes this all the better.
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
With advanced editing you could darken the sky even more - but this has a nice impact as is. I like the composition witht eh path in the corner and the silvery clouds on the thirds line.
Post actions
maybe a little too much burn on the top part.
Post actions
Nice feeling reminiscent of Ansel Adams. Less central composition would be better.
Post actions
Post actions
Great pic. But are we to believe that no advance editing was involved in that halo around the tree. Actually, even admitting this, the dodging could be less obvious. For these reasons - 6.
Post actions
This is one of the best in the challenge, if a bit oversharpened.
Post actions
beautiful shot and great in b & w
Post actions
DNMC
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
