Author Thread
Comments Made During the Challenge
01/28/2006 05:25:10 PMPost actions
This image doesn't have the impact that I think you were looking for. It is too centered and too far from the girl to convey the emotions of grief and longing.
01/26/2006 10:19:33 PMPost actions
Very nice composition, however, the photo is too white washed/over-exposed for me...
01/26/2006 05:48:45 AMPost actions
Photographer found comment helpful.
01/23/2006 06:49:28 PMPost actions
The small size of image makes it difficult to assess. The image is over-exposed - thus the sky blown out. Seems to have a lot of noise too.
Photographer found comment helpful.
01/22/2006 07:15:46 AMPost actions
I think the photo is a bit too small, and also seems to be very overexposed in the sky.
Photographer found comment helpful.
01/22/2006 04:24:31 AMPost actions
This doesn't grab me; and I think it is because it is so flat, and the lady looks like a tourist and not a mourner.
Photographer found comment helpful.
01/21/2006 04:40:32 PMPost actions
Use of the full 640 pixel limit is highly recommended.
Other than that, I don't really like the bright light in this.
Photographer found comment helpful.
01/20/2006 04:11:07 PMPost actions
This picture could be so powerful with more contrast and without the distracting blown out sky. 6
Photographer found comment helpful.
01/19/2006 01:03:48 PMPost actions
The message of the image has some merit. Some problems I see:
- you're shooting right at the sun, so the glare is very harsh
- it's too small and looks pixel-y
- the composition is overly busy (could you have gotten closer and to the side?)
- the grey tones are overly dominant here (some editing on contrast may have helped)
Hope this helps.
Photographer found comment helpful.
01/18/2006 10:24:22 PMPost actions
8 from me....a little too washed out and seems slightly blurry...but I still like it!
Photographer found comment helpful.
01/18/2006 06:48:14 PMPost actions
sizeis to small,the blow out in the upper left is to harsh
over all a bit soft
Photographer found comment helpful.
01/16/2006 08:00:48 AMPost actions
Blown out. A little crooked. Not in focus. Too small. Grainy. Indistinct.
And absolutely fittingly so.
A very good demonstration how technical perfection is not the same as emotional impact. Nice use of what I am guessing is a less than perfect medium.
Photographer found comment helpful.