Author Thread
Post actions
the grain is a little too out of control, but the right idea. very nicely observed, ashame that it didn't go higher. it really nailed the challenge, imho. better luck next time, keep it up!
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
I like the grain, hope this scores well.
Post actions
I like the gritty effect.
Post actions
i like the grainy effect on this picture, its well captured and reflects city life well in my experience
Post actions
Not sure if I like the mood with the use of grain?
Post actions
Nice capture. Speaks to the subject well and I like the choice of B/W and grain.
Post actions
i like the feel of this photo
Post actions
Very nice, I like the use of grain and B&W, really give it that 'mundane activity' look.
Post actions
I think you OD'd on the "film grain," but it's still a good shot. (I'm surprised no one on board hit you for taking his or her picture — 8-D.)
Post actions
B/W really works well for this, also like soft focus and composition
Post actions
A little grainy and perspective seems a bit confined
Post actions
Great shot! Would have liked to seen this with less noise.
Post actions
A little too grainy for my taste but the concept is good. 8
Post actions
ohhh how entertaining public transportation can be! i kind of like the image grain here... did u add that in? either way, it works..nice black and white
Post actions
Nice... Wish i lived in a city with so much life and confusion ;) like the shot!
Post actions
Great shot. It really personifies the stereotype of city living. The composition and b&w really work well.
Post actions
This is perfect for the challenge, and I love the grittiness of the shot. 8.
Post actions
the graininess captures the feel of a subway car well. I sense all four lives.
Post actions
Composition is ok. The choice of subject matter is ok. The image quality is ok. Has potential of being really creative. - 5
Post actions
I liked the use of grain on this one.
Post actions
I like the black and white, and the graininess is ok as well. Perhaps a more contrasty / dynamic image would be good - curves would have helped deal with the bright lights if doing this. I do like the framing and composition (particularly the nearest person). Good work.
Post actions
i like how the photo has a sort of texture
Post actions
Now this is the city feeling I remember. Thanks for the good memories. The only thing missing is the strange old man that used to ramble odd things. Good photo.
Post actions
I love the composition. I suspect some people might not like the image grain so much.
Post actions
Post actions
A very strong potrayal of city life. Good use of grain too.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
