dispite of the reflection in the ball, I like it. The DoF really works here. Maybe the ribbon could've been better when it ended inside the frame. gave you a 7
Great focus, lighting and color. The ribbon is cropped a little tight on the bottom (imho), I'd like to see the whole ribbon in the frame (ie, not include a longer ribbon, but cut it so it fits in the composition shown). Definitely a good candidate for a holiday catalog.
nice dof and composition. really need a tent to shoot this kind of thing, unless the reflection is relevant, but it's too small to tell. beautiful work, really.
the reflection of the room in the ball really kills the shot, everything else is so well done and with so much attention to details, this being an advanced challenge i would have suggested selecing that area with a feathered selection and applying a guassian blur to remove that reflection, or manually with the blur tool... or with the clone tool...