I like the serenity of this. I didn't comment during the challenge but gave it an 8. Really nice with the single tree to the left and lots of negative space. The overall single tonality of the image ties it all together. Very pretty!
Beautiful, subtle serene, need I go on? The placement of the cloud above the tree is perfect, I think it adds to the serenity of the scene, some people would like it over on the right to balance the tree. Bumped up to 9.
I camped on a lake like this more than once and your extraordinary photo captures a sweet feel of nostalgia for me. The soft light and orange hues are highlights of this professional looking shot. 9
My top three for this challenge are all landscapes. This one is the same scene as the other shot of the same location. There is a nice flow of line in both pics as well as the nice smooth early morning rendition of calm colors. I'm unsure which crop I like more.
This is a beautiful shot, it combines 2 really cool things...silhouettes and reflections and is composed really well what with the shore line leading the eye in. Very nice.