Author Thread
Post actions
This image was disqualified from the challenge. Due to the nature of the disqualification, I am not going to perform the critique of this image.Message edited by HBunch - Removed Critique Club status.
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
love the concept. The colours may have popped better if you had used a black background. As it is, the white labels and the blue labels tend to blend more into the background and not give it as much definition as it could otherwise have.
Post actions
very original but you could havedone soemthing about the background or done it on glass and illuminate it differently. it lacks depth composition-wise
Post actions
Post actions
Very Creative. The pic is kinda' flat but I know setup was tough. You may get dq'd b/c of the text / artist's signature though.
Post actions
Post actions
so creative1!!! I need one fo those!
Post actions
here we go! an interesting way to display a collection! a fun shot.
Post actions
I feel like so many people missed the point of "collections", and took photos of a page of a stamp book, or a pile of polished rocks sitting on a table. I think "CD Fish" exemplifies the qualities of creative photography, and outside of being a cool photograph is a really cool mural! The execution is a 7 or so, but I feel like the concept is an easy ten. Eight from me!
Post actions
Good use of those "free" CDs. Are you the artist as well? Might benefit from white level adjustment.
Post actions
This is pretty cool, but is it art or a collection?
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
Haha, I remember. Some of the CD's fell off last year when we did this.
Post actions
Post actions
great picasso trigger! I've been meaning to do something with those extra aol discs...
Post actions
Being a photo of another piece of art, the photo qualities that I am now looking for are the same for a documentation pic. The corners are dark and the flash doesn't seem even.
Post actions
This is a fun idea. Is it yours or in a gallery?
Post actions
Cool. The only this I could mention is poor background...9
Post actions
nice....was there a map for this thing after the TV commercial came out??
Post actions
That has got to be the coolest piece of physical art Ive ever seen!
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
