I love the composition in this photograph. The natural framing of the tree branches around the top and the wheat (?) along the bottom is terrific. I would have been very tempted to not even add an additional border...
Absolutely beautiful framing of the image by the tree branches above and the grasses below. Just not a whole lot of interesting subject matter in the center part of the photo. Also, I'm kinda neutral about the B&W.
Composition: Nice use of trees to border the pic. Looks like it needs rotating though..
Technical: Nice colour and focus. I think I might have opted for a simpler border, with the use of trees.
Meets challenge: Yes
Overall impression: Nice, but the horizon angle detracts from the shot.