I think you were defiantly thinking outside the normal box with your "Different" entry into the Odd Challenge. I like the approach you chose, they were actually a few different egg ideas out there and your did not look like any of the rest. Also great choice on green apple to draw attention in. I think the photo itself could have used a couple of different things to get voted higher. Possibly the focus seems a little soft, I know how hard focusing can be depending on the environment and subject. The focus also could have been affected by the flash. I might have tried a couple of different angles and perspectives for that different look. Also I might have tried that different angle showing less of your back drop or change the color of your backdrop. The box almost blends into the background. I might even play with adjusting the contrast to give the box more depth. Overall I think you had an excellent idea keep up the good work.
The focus wasn't a very well done job on this shot, I originally gave it a 5, but have to drop it down to a 4 because of that. It's an innovative thought compared to other egg users. The cloth used as a background doesn't work very well for the picture, in my opinion. It needs something that will contrast the container colour. It could have turned out a better shot. That's what I think at least.