Author Thread
11/19/2005 05:14:38 PMPost actions
A shot that fully deserved a top 5 finish. Maybe you should stick to only B&W?!
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/16/2005 12:41:52 PMPost actions
Congrats on your top 5 finish. Very timely image.
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/16/2005 01:55:14 AMPost actions
A good artistic rendition. Congratulations on your top 5 finish.
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/16/2005 12:44:30 AMPost actions
John, WaaHoo!! Way to go Utah. You really caught the drama of the scene and the garbage that mixes in. Wonderful.
Becky
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/16/2005 12:23:03 AMPost actions
YAAHOO! Congrats John on your 5th! errrr 4th that is!Message edited by author 2005-11-20 14:35:50.
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/16/2005 12:19:16 AMPost actions
Garbage ... simply garbage ... 5th place garbage that is, way to go John, this was a great study of everyday life.
Photographer found comment helpful.
Comments Made During the Challenge
11/15/2005 01:25:00 PMPost actions
Interesting composition, although the truck is either too central or too motion blurred.
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/15/2005 08:05:58 AMPost actions
My only 10 score in this challenge.
The isolation and desolation are really communicated well, the movement of the lorry helps a lot there and the lines of the fence and road leading off to the left into the mountains add an uneasy feeling. This is the only B&W conversion which works really well in this challenge.
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/14/2005 12:40:44 PMPost actions
I like the lines of the photo, and I think having chosen b&w is a good choice for it. Good luck.
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/13/2005 06:02:27 PMPost actions
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/12/2005 10:00:20 PMPost actions
I love this shot! In my top three.
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/12/2005 12:36:31 PMPost actions
wicked shot. love the blurring on the truck. fantastic picture!
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/11/2005 11:01:23 PMPost actions
9
Probably a 10 if the truck weren't in the background and there was more detail in the weeds on the left side of the fence. Top 10 for sure.
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/11/2005 12:50:21 PMPost actions
one of my favorites in this challenge, certianly meets the challenge - love the coloring and sharpness - and blur of the truck - very nice image to look at - nice work :)
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/10/2005 06:45:25 PMPost actions
nice ir effect. like the dof and shards of old bag caught on the fence. nicely done.
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/10/2005 02:32:58 PMPost actions
A really interesting take. Great detail and a really strong leading line.
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/09/2005 10:53:33 PMPost actions
I don't know where to start, everthing is great about this photo. I'd have to say I like the contrast and composition of this photo best. It has very good tone and mood also.
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/09/2005 08:07:14 PMPost actions
I almost did something similar but I think you really pulled it off. The semi is a great touch
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/09/2005 08:04:15 PMPost actions
very nice shot. i love how you got the truck in the back, it balances the whole picture.
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/09/2005 02:11:42 PMPost actions
This is nice. I like the ominous feeling the speeding truck give to this picture. Very nice composition and B&W suits this picture very well.
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/09/2005 02:06:52 PMPost actions
This is one of the more interesting photos here. I like the foreground and background subjects. The focus on the garbage makes clear the main subject. Good job.
I give you a 10.
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/09/2005 01:25:54 PMPost actions
Cant think of any critism for this shot, its simply a good one! 10
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/09/2005 08:20:36 AMPost actions
Really nice photo :) How long did you have to wait for the truck? 8
Photographer found comment helpful.
11/09/2005 08:05:34 AMPost actions
Beautiful study in b/w. I'm also (and this is going to sound weird) REFRESHED to see a non-staged shot in this challenge. Great job and good luck!
Photographer found comment helpful.