this is really just too dark. i'd like to see the light play more with the interesting curves and textures of the bowl. but as is, it's mostly just dark tones and then a central reflection on the bowl. 4.
I would like to see a touch more lighting on this. I would like to be able to make out a little more of what it is around the left side. Good detail in the area that has the "most" amount of light though
The lighting you do have here defines the holes of the object, but I'm still not sure what it is. Perhaps it's too low key! Oh well. Maybe a wisp of smoke would help? The off center composition seems effective at helping this object appear to be in a larger space.
I think the lighting is a bit flat. It may have looked better and more intriguing with directional lighting, revealing the unusual form of the container. [6]
adjusting my screen made this work for me I had you at a lower number but made another pass....I spent some time reading forums and feel a lot of us got tagged for issues out of our hands...anyway nice job! 8