Author Thread
Post actions
Great mood here! Grain is very effective !!!!!!!!
Post actions
This image belongs in the top ten. It is an outstanding effort with a mood that moves the viewer. Yes, many voters avoid the dark rendition but this is their loss.
Post actions
This is awesome, looks like it belongs in a O'Brian novel.
Post actions
slippy's a mother-freaken baddass
Post actions
Great shot Slippy! Surprised didn't finish higher.
Post actions
WHAT!!!! I thought this one was going into the top 10 for sure!!!
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Grain that bites the viewer. A very good subject for this challenge.
Post actions
A good example of grainy b&w photo
Post actions
Great sky. The crop is excellent, showing just enough of the boat to add impact. Nice job. The only thing is it seemed a little dark to me, but it may have gotten muddy if you lightened it up anymore. Hard to say.
Post actions
this is a great shot well framed, but the burning in the sky is very aparent...also as far as the older photo look goes u did well, but i think as with many shots in this challenge the grain level is just higher than it could really ever be or should be....its just foggy with grain, takes away from the image more than adds a key helping element
Post actions
Great placement and composition.
Post actions
My favorite image for this challenge. The grain really makes it feel like a dark and dreary day. Would expect to see whitecaps on the water even.
Post actions
Powerful! The image grain adds a lot to it. Congratulations!
Post actions
Grain enhances the mood here, well done.
Post actions
Nice dark and gritty feel to it.
Post actions
Good image. The composition is nice and the grain, along with the excellent processing, adds a nice mood.
Post actions
Bigtime grain. I love it. It adds to the old or even "ghostly" quality of the picture. 9
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
