I hope this doesn't offend any dwarves on DPC! I took this picture to add to a photograph from Yosemite that had a very hobbitish feel to it with crooked trees and mist and I wanted to edit myself into it and alas I was too big.
Statistics
Place: 26 out of 138 Avg (all users): 6.2661 Avg (commenters): 6.9333 Avg (participants): 6.2326 Avg (non-participants): 6.3421 Views since voting: 2694 Votes: 124 Comments: 19 Favorites: 2 (view)
I have seen this image a few times and must say that it has impact. Also, the way you framed it goes well with the imagery itself. The horizontal is slightly off but perhaps you wanted it that way.
Nice finish! Glad you're back in the game - can't wait to see how hot we can fire up our page. (my shots this week are all mid 5's, so ... nothing at all cookin).
You got DQ there for a bit, but I see it's back. What nice luck! You are definately off centered, but the subject here really doesn't do much for me. I was able to read your description and think this would make a good shot for something like what you were going to do, but individually, it's not too interesting. Lighting is good, and focus and clarity are good. Don't care for the border. Oh, your DQ request wasn't for the border, it was for technique used to make you look short. Guess they thought editing could have been used. And it COULD have, but glad that wasn't the case. :)
~Heather~
Interesting framing/border here. The off centeredness here suggests that this guy--you--has more to him than the photograph could portray, so you've created a negative space. Does that make sense? Well, nice shot.
So, how many comments are you getting about how you did your border and whether it's legal? I trust it's legal, I'd be curious to find out how you did it after the challenge though. As for the photo, it meets the challenge, great b&w with nice amounts of contrast, good lighting. Good job :)