Looks a bit oversharpened on my screen, there is a very distinctive halo around just about everything in the shot but otherwise I like this shot, fitting for the theme and the composition is good. 6 from me.
BINGO!
A small hill in a foreground overlaps with background in a very bad way
(again, I don't know the word in english).
If there wasn0t for that little detail, this pic would be my fav so far.
And yes, clean your sensor (CMOS) you have some dust on it.
I really love the crispness in this photo - terrific depth of field.
I only wish the reflection were clearer, but I can see that the ripples are caused by wind, not anything that you had control over. So it may not be possible to improve much on this shot.
Nice. (Maybe a little too over sharpened.) There are just so many water shots that in order to "Creatively photograph a reflecting surface that is not a mirror" and stand above the rest there has to be some grabber. I will be back to re-evaluate after I look through the rest of the shots.