Nice image of someone deep in thought, but it doesn't give me a visual reflection. Also, the image is very, very small. It would certainly have more impact if it were the full 640 pixels on the largest dimension, which is allowed in the regulations.
If there is a reflecting surface in this picture I fail to see it, which reduce the score on this photo. Probably from others as well, since it is not obvious how this meets the challenge.
I suggest to always submit your photos at the largest allowed size in order to lose as little detail as possible in the submission. Composition is good, but the image is (IMHO) too small to comment on technical details such as focus, grain, DOF etc.
I really like this black and white photo, I would like it to have been larger though. My first impression was that I would have used a different background but the more I look at it the more I think this was the perfect background for this shot. Only criticism maybe a little bright at bottom left. 9
This is a very nice portrait. But I'm trying to find indicators that this is a reflection. I don't see any borders and I can't make out any text that might be reversed. Without some indication that this is a reflection, I'm afaid it won't score very strongly. You've succeeded too well it appears.
Photo is too small. I also don't see any reflections unless the entire image is a reflection. But, as I said, photo is too small, therefore unable to tell.