I guess there were just too many pics of lakes and leaves for people to distinguish between good and bad. I gave you a 9, your reflection is nearly flawless. Nice job.
Very rich and crisp - I really like this one. I especially lke how clear the reflection is. And the leaves floating in the foreground add a nice element of interest, too.
Very Nice. There are just so many water shots that in order to "Creatively photograph a reflecting surface that is not a mirror" and stand above the rest there has to be some grabber. I will be back to re-evaluate after I look through the rest of the shots.