This picture is amazing, ive never seen a better photo in my life, i really think you should have gotten first. As an expierenced photographer myself i see your point of view and iwouldnt worry about all the crap these nimwits and numskulls are giving you.
actually guys i appreciate your support and everything but i wasnt in this to do anything more than fulfill clay's wet dream of pissing off some guy that told him "might as well just submit a blank picture".
i took this in my fridge with the door closed, macro, at a canister of oj.
Wow. There are some REALLY stupid f*cking people on this site. Jesus christ it hurts to see the stupidity. I voted your picture a 10 because it was totally against what some of the goons on this site think. I feel sorry you had to sit an entire week listening to some of the most rediculous comments ever left for an image.
i'm not sure that this is entirely "creative", because a lot of people probably had the same idea, but i do admire the fact that you submitted it. now, if we could just get it to win, that would be a statement.
This is without question the most dramatic shadow of the challenge - However, If I were to offer a little criticism it would be to zoom out a little. You might adjust the shutter speed a little and I cant help but wonder what this would look like in color. E for effort :) Ooooo, did you here that? I think Ansel Adams just rolled over.
If you were trying to see how low you could score you won that one with me. THERE IS NOTHING IN YOUR PICTURE, but you know that. I would say at least you tried but it looks like you didn't, you win the lowest sore I give out award. Score 1 if threre was a 0 it would be yours. ----------- Corey
HaHaHaHaHaHaHaHa. I can't decide if you are extremely brave, talented, or lazy. :-) Obviously, I can't comment on the composition, focus, DOF, or any of that other stuff, so we'll just leave it like this. HA>
this is a shadow of what? I don't believe it is a shadow at all. is this even a photo? this is not even darkness. there is absolutely no substance to this. Is this what you saw? Where was your head? Was your camera there too? Well, put your head back up there and take deep breaths. Leave your camera out this time so someone who can figure out how to use it can take your picture for the city idiot challenge. sorry----- 1---isn't a 1 worse than a 0? I hope so
Or 'A Picture of a Black Sheep In a Coal Mine' I have one of a white sheep in a blizard. Why are you wasting my time with this placeholder for, I am assuming, some verry nasty comments.
All shadow! Unique perspective, but I wouldn't hang it on my wall or buy a copy of this shot. Is there anything to see in this shot?) Other than black. Photo 1 Creativity 9 Shadows 3 (takes your chances....) total 5 (best I could muster)
I really like the simplicity of the tonal range in this photo. The complications caused by contrasts, sharpness, and focus issues are not present in this image. I also really like the way that the pixels are aligned in nice vertical and horizontal rows, creating a nice series of geometries that tease my eyes... I want a signed print of this one when the challenge is over...
I really dont know whether to give this a 1 or a 10. As a photo, it fails miserably. As a peice of conceptual art, its got a weak concept, nothing visually interesting, and no skill needed to make it. So thats a 10, then.