Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
trees and grass seem a little overproccessed to me
Post actions
This is beautiful. The autumn colors and the reflections in the water. Maybe slightly oversharpened, but this is lovely. Great job!
Post actions
The vegetation seems to be a bit over saturated.
Post actions
looks a little heavy on the sharpening.
Post actions
I'm not a big fan of the highly sharpened look. The clouds look cool, but all the foliage looks wrong.
Post actions
Post actions
beautiful landscape but it seems oversharpened
Post actions
It's difficult to tell what happened here but I assume you over sharpened during the post processing.
Post actions
This is a beautiful scene and well captured. Great DOF and sharpness.
Post actions
beautiful scene - real shame that is over-sharpened to the point of distraction
Post actions
Post actions
What a pretty scene - I love the reflections and the clouds. what caused the effect in the grasses and leaves? Perhaps NOT most flattering to the gorgeous scene.
Post actions
the composition is very nice and nice clouds as well, but the sharpness hurts the eye...
Post actions
The wide angle is evident. The foreground use adds soe depth for the wide angle to hold on to. A couple of things about the photo trouble me. It feels like there is too much noise in the image, especially in the blues of the sky and the reflection. Also, the grasses look a little oversharpened. If I'm wrong on my assessment of the USM, please forgive me, it just feels like the foreground colours and whites give the sense of too much sharpening. JMO.
Post actions
could have been a very good shot if you hadn't oversharpened it
Post actions
Post actions
Nice framing. Looks very over-sharpened on my monitor.
Post actions
A promising scene, but the wild colors and noisy artifacts make the image look as if it were taken with a video camera.Too much JPEG compression and/or oversharpening?
Post actions
wow, oversharpening like AHHH!H!!!
Post actions
Nice choice of subject. Great scene and good use of wide angle. Looks kind of over sharpened though, seems pixelated.
Post actions
Post actions
I love the image, the contrast seems touch high for my taste.
Post actions
looks way overly sharpened to me..
Post actions
seems a bit over sharpened to me
Post actions
wow, very pretty...!!! Great job..!! Best one yet..!! 10
Post actions
This could have been a high rating for me except that it is so over-sharpened that the grass in the front and the orange trees look like they are made of neon. I would love to see this without the sharpening.
Post actions
a bit too much saturated and sharpened for my taste. Looks not natural :(
Post actions
WOW What a stunning reflection. The sky and clouds are wonderful as a backdrop to the red, yellow and green. For some reason, the ground colors seem a tad over saturated. Maybe it's just me.
Post actions
The composition of this shot is nice, and it seems quite grainy on my screen.
Post actions
wayyyyyyyyyyyyy over sharpened. eeeeek. This would have been a great picture.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
