The colors are interesting but I have a big problem with the lips themselves. For being the main focus of the image they are very soft and the focus just isn't there. Part of it could be the lipstick bleeding but if you are going to do a photo so concentrated on a pair of lips make sure your model has lip liner on to stop the lipstick bleeding.
You stated you used lots of neatimage to get the plastic look to it, it just doesn't work for me. The purpose for plastic surgery and collogen injections is not to look like plastic it is to look real without imprefections.
I can't stop being distracted by the right side of the mouth even though your focus is to the left top, the right bottom is so out of focus and bright it takes all the attention from the needle and upperlip.
As for meeting the challenge, doesn't to me. Had there been a drop of liquid even if it was water or cooking oil visible from around the needle then it would but without the title all it is is a photo of vanity.
Er, eww. On-topic, yeah. Interesting expression. Skin tone very bright, lighting too bright overall I think. However those things with colours contrast which helps a bit.
I'm not sure what the message is here but this photo really had an emotional impact on me. It's kind of gross and drained the blood out of me but I like the way you've isolated the lips with a very narrow DOF. I also like the pale colors of the face. Is this really an injection of some kind? It looks so real I'm wondering where the drop of blood is? Very effective!
Ouch... this can't be real?! Great skin tones you've captured. Good saturation and lighting. Border works well here. How did you get everything other than the syringe and lips so blurred? 9
Yow! What an unpleasant concept! I don't really care for the lighting in this photo - it's not very attractive. But then again, the idea of pumping one's lips full of stuff is not an attractive idea, and does not always yield attractive results.
I dont know what you did but the face of this person looks like it was softened in an editing program after the fact. I'm sorry but I dont like the effect of it.
This one works for me - especially the upturned lip emphasising the sense of disgust at cosmetic surgery. However, the marks on the chin and the general fuzziness of the image bother me a little.
Excellent idea and message. Picture seems a little washed out in areas though, not sure if this was done intentionally? Also, there are blotches on the chin and jawline. Excellent pic