COMPOSITION An absolutely breathtaking shot. Composition split evenly top to bottom with the water surface just short of glass-like. I love the portrait orientation which emphasizes the stature of the masts. Brilliant work!
TECHNIQUE The thing that's so striking about this image is the absolute perfection of the lighting. I can't image what the source of light is that makes the boats' hulls glow in such a creamy soft hue. The center one is a little yellow but that is far from bad - it adds a little splash of color. I'm also struck by your perfect control of the tonal range, from inky black water and sky to softly glowing white boats. Focus is sharp and I almost get a feel of three dimensionality from the forest of masts. I looked hard but I can't find anything to criticize!
OVERALL IMPACT I admit that I'm a bit blown away by this photo. It shows a great eye for composition and superb attention to detail, both in the shooting and the presentation. You give no details in your photographer's comment or photo information, so I can't tell what you were aiming for, or how you achieved it in-camera or post processing, but I say you scored a hit. Your commenters certainly liked it as well, but I'm a little surprised the final score wasn't higher. 6.14 is very respectable, but I liked it a lot and thought maybe it deserved a higher finish.
I am trying to comment on all photos this week. I really don't know what to say about this photo. Without a title this would not have as much impact, but with the title It really is a romantic setting. Good job.
Absolutely stunning! Love it, think it fits the challenge and the title category well. Wow, i'm guessing this will soon be available as a print! It's wonderful.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.