Author Thread
Post actions
Message edited by HBunch - Removed Critique Club status.
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Post actions
I am not sure about the frame, but great thinking with this.
Post actions
hmmm...would have been cooler if the pic was closer to where it splits
Post actions
You have a winner. This is excellent. The frame helps the image a lot. 9
Post actions
Nice interpretation. I may have picked the spot where it branches from itself to accent it but I like how its included. Good job.
Post actions
I think this would have been more effective if you had taken it from a lower point of view and showed more of the tracks going off into the distance.
Post actions
stunning, just love it, sorry no input - just admiration
Post actions
Nice lines and composition. Good focus and I think the B/W works well. Not sure about the border though.
Post actions
I think this picture would be more interesting if it had been cropped with the tracks off center.
Post actions
Nice job on this shot. I like your choice to show detail in the track. Again...nice job.
Post actions
Great angle and take on the challenge!
Post actions
Strong tonal range usage. The composition is off for me - too centered and not enough of the actual branching. I think a slightly lower shooting angle would have given a stronger composition. I do like the hardware in the foreground. 6
Post actions
The subject which is the branch takes a backseat by being too far away from the viewer and thus out of focus. I like the different approach though.
Post actions
Post actions
Good Job, I like your take on it. 9
Post actions
think the perspective would be a little bit better by the camera being just a little lower
Post actions
very nice black and white photo. like the composition a lot. 9
Post actions
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
