photo of alps from airplane flying from venice to paris. removed colors, adjusted contrast, cloned out some of the dirt from the window, sharpened and resized.
Statistics
Place: 22 out of 343 Avg (all users): 6.3307 Avg (commenters): 7.8571 Avg (participants): 6.1509 Avg (non-participants): 6.6224 Views since voting: 1189 Views during voting: 382 Votes: 257 Comments: 18 Favorites: 1 (view)
COMPOSITION Airplane window shots can be a pain. You have access to some pretty incredible scenery from a great vantage point, but not much control over the details. This is a great capture under those circumstances, catching both foreground peaks with lots of detail and background mountains lost a bit in the haze of distance. Love the combination of clouds, snow and dark rock. You had great light and took full advantage of the opportunity.
TECHNIQUE Your end result looks very good, and you achieved a very respectable score in the challenge, so your technique was obviously successful. I wonder if you really only used desat and contrast enhancement to achieve the BW effect though. If you're using photoshop, you might also experiement with channel mixer to achieve other types of BW effect. There are many, many ways to achieve the BW look, don't limit yourself to simple desat/contrast adjustments! I agree with the commenter who observed that you had achieved an Ansel Adams-type look. It catches the eye!
OVERALL IMPACT Not many people can resist a second or third look at a compelling landscape shot, especially one with an unusual viewpoint and a sweeping grandure. You have certainly done that here. The image is eye-catching and and well composed. Not many people could pass by quickly with this pic. Nice job!
This is great! I'm new at this, so.... I really like how the clouds are drifting over the mountain tops, the contrast b/n black and white, and the dark sky, it's beautiful!