Author Thread
Post actions
Very cool shot. Didn't vote on this challenge, but I would have given it a high score. Lovely reflection.
Post actions
Greetings from the Critique Club!
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
ooooooooo.... this is really nice accept for the fact that i think it would been cooler if the tree was bigger
Post actions
i wish the photo could have been tighter on the branch itself. to much water in the photo. nice lighting and i like the reflections in the water.
Post actions
The image is a bit dark but nice reflection.
Post actions
nice shot id like to see this shot a little tighter though
Post actions
Wow...awesome lighting. I'm impressed.
Post actions
could have been cropped tighter for me, or more dark on the right and top to balance it out, very pretty,
Post actions
It looks cool, but maybe it's just a little too dark.
Post actions
This shot feels top heavy. Cropping the bottom about half way up to the lower reflected branch would give it more balance. Perhaps the reflected branches need more strength. On the other hand, the light branches contrast well against the darkness.
Post actions
I like the reflection, but I think the trees on the left are a little too dark
Post actions
nice reflection in water to 'complete' the hidden half of tree.
Post actions
lighting good, composition good, POV good, focus good. I don't get much of a sense of place with the current crop - wish there was more. 6
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
Love this one. Great job overall!
Post actions
Post actions
I like the dark feel of the photo...
Post actions
I'm not a techinical person, but I like the reflection and colors. I do wonder how this photo would look as a horizontal image because the branch itself is horizontal?
Post actions
Post actions
Very nice, I would have cropped more from the bottom to add strength.
Post actions
Nicely balanced composition, and subtle line picked out with the light.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
