the bottom half of this is terrific, the top half - the background and the shoe are so close to the same color that it creates kind of a bland image - love the idea and creativity though - 7
Nice contrast to all the human shoe entries. I like your vertical composition, and crispness. It could just be my monitor, but some of the highlights are quite bright.
Clever and original in terms of idea - not many horse shoes in the challenge - but, for me, lacking in real appeal - there's not enough to hold me in this image, to keep my interest coming back again and again.