I like the selective desat. The way you chose to present this image has harmed your overall score. The roated boarder is not appealing to the eye. You would have been better off to have cropped the image.
Sorry to be blunt, but selective desaturation and a gimmicky frame are not going to improve a photo unless it's really bold and interesting to begin with.
Sorry but not at all a fan of the frame, normally I don´t comment on them at all but this one just so firmly grasps at my attention that it took me a second to notice the shot itself and to be honest I don´t care for it at all. I feel the the shot itself is slightly worse than average in this challenge, the alignment of the shoes is kind of interesting but the lighting is poor, the shadow in the back is too dark and big parts of the shoes have blown out highlights. 3 from me, would have given 4 if it weren´t for the frame.
The skewed frame does nothing for the picture at all, and doesn't relate to it in any way. The lighting is odd with the line of sunlight across the top of the picture. Nothing is in focus. The theme seems uninspiring, it's a crescent shape alright, but that's all it is, just like an untidy pile of kids trainers on your lawn.