I really like your angle on the lights. I think that it is great. I would have liked to see "more" of the dock and I wish that the barge in the water wasn't there. But I guess that it would be hard to take a picure of a dock with no boats, huh? Overall, I think that it is a nice picture, maybe some cropping would improve it, but you have a good eye for interesting angles. There are a few harsh shadows, but maybe that was your intent. I can also see that this shot would be very neat at night with the lights on. I hope this helped you, good luck in future challenges, by the way...you hit the theme perfectly!!
Looks lik it could use a CCW rotation. Grant it you might have rotated CW to have the poles straight, but the horizon is off. Might have a good idea to use some distortion correction if you had it. Like the perspective and the great receding line of the lights.
I like the leading lines of the lamps. This image would be stronger if there was something at the end of the trail of lamps. I find the uneven horizon distracting.
When the horizon's at such a shallow angle off the norm, it should really be leveled out - it wouldn't detract from the half hooped lights at all (which would also benefit from having their verticals straight up). If you'd caught the ferry a few seconds later with the row of lights pointing directly at it without obscuring it, you would have been onto a perfect 10!.
I do like the intersection of one light with the next.
Cool idea. I think this photo would have more visual impact if you had gone into Photoshop, selected the entire image, selected "Free Transform", then right-clicked and selected "Distort". Then you could have pulled on moved around the corner handles until you had all the verticals (lamp posts, etc.) aligned absolutely veritcal. Also, you always want the horizon completely horizontal when water is involved. I probably would have played with the sky a little to make it slightly darker and bluer at the top and gradually reach its natural color/tone near the horizon. Just a couple of ideas for what its worth.
good composition, I like these kind of opportunities to shoot. Looks like it might need to be rotated 1 or 2 degrees to the left maybe. The sky blends into the shot so well the colors all run together. Tough conditions to shoot in!. A cool sunset or rise, clouds, night shot would be great if all the lights light up.......5
I like the subject idea here but the photo feels very off balance, like everything is falling to the right side of the photograph. This could be lessened by straightening out the horizon, or perhaps even by showing more deck.