Author Thread
Post actions
** Greetings from the Critique Club **
Post actions
wow, a top twenty finish, I only joined this site a couple of weeks ago so I'm really pleased. Thanks for all of the constructive comments and the praise!! With a busy work life and two kids and a self build my photography is only ever based on grab shots so I'm really pleased with this one.
Post actions
i was sure it will be top 3..
Post actions
I loved this one. Congratulations on your top Twenty Finish.
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
The hard part about trying to make a perspective shot like this work it making sure that the lighting of both subjects match up and add to the illusion. Unfortunately the lighting here doesn't match. It makes it obvious how the 'illusion' was done...
Post actions
A great use of a wide angle here. Perfect execution. How many times did you have to try this to get it just right?
Post actions
Clever! I like the overall composition and choice of subject. Nicely done. 8
Post actions
works very well
Post actions
Great concept I thinkif there were more detail in theboot it would look more convincing
Post actions
very nice use of percpective. Good luck
Post actions
Great composition and control over exposure & lighting! (7)
Post actions
this has great potential, maybe a little mud or something flying from the shoe would really add to this-8
Post actions
Pretty good idea here...good job...7
Post actions
Cute and very funny. Another avenue to explore and heighten the illusion is to have found or made from clay a small brick to hold right in the fisted hand as if you were lifting it from the top of the structure.
Post actions
Great use of perspective. Everything is nicely sharp throughout.
Post actions
Effective illusion although the person is a little too close to the camera giving a little blurred look..
Post actions
the rest of the body is distracting in the photo it could have been better without that part in.
Post actions
not really believeable, unfortunate angle
Post actions
Well taken, great DOF. The image works really well.
Post actions
The illusion is good. You have come accross the problem of a balance of expsure between foreground and background. I would prefer a little more definition on the leg and shoe to really lift this image
Post actions
Nice shot... it appears to be lacking a bit in crisp focus, and the colors are somewhat dull, but there is a clear illusion and I like the crop job.
Post actions
Well spotted and implemented - 9
Post actions
good illusion, I like.....
Post actions
Interesting perspective. Cool image
Post actions
AARRRGGGG!!! Look out! Nice creative capture!
Post actions
Nice use of angle to create the illusion of size. IMHO, the colors could be bumped up a bit, but the detail and scale is good.
Post actions
great idea - great capture - makes you think …. hmmmmm
Post actions
great effect, i love how its already demolished a little about where your foot would land
Post actions
good eye for a photo op for this challenge, perspective may not be quite right, but definately you get props for seeing the opportunity
Post actions
Nice but may want to move the "person" back a little. He is too far forward.
Post actions
wonderful interpretation and shot
Post actions
First Impression: Nice pose. A bit dark on the giant compared to the lighter bricks.
Post actions
Hehe, Nice!! Good illusion. Color is good, detail is good.
Post actions
this is nice, i really like it amazing shot
Post actions
Clever. Could use a bit more saturation. 9
Post actions
Great perspective ! The effect really works !
Post actions
Clever, very clever!!!!!!!!!
Post actions
Good job on this illusion. Composed nicely and I like the angle. My only complaint...the subjects appear a little dark and dull. 9
Post actions
This would have been a lot stronger entry if your angle was a little different. The idea is good - the foot is in the wrong place.
Post actions
Post actions
Great idea!!! But I hope that the demolition was done by the foot LOL
Post actions
looks like fun! SMASH! i wish it was really and there was an "after" photo hah
Post actions
This is pretty good! For a better effect, I think you should have been a couple more feet behind where you are right now so that it really looks like you're trampling on the building :)
Post actions
Great illusion! Can you say, "crotch shot?". lol!
Post actions
This is a great illusion a real trick photography shot. It is just a shame you couldn't get a day with a better sky as it seems a little bright for this image. But overall a great shot 8
Post actions
i would like this more if you didn't see so much of the person (especially their butt)
Post actions
now this is an illusion... well done... i love the naturalness here.... 8
Post actions
Post actions
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
