I gave this photo a 9 as I stated below and it was done totally different then the way I had thought you did it. Still VERY well done and this is exactly the reason I say people should stop and look at the photos instead of rushing thru them. Again very well done and keep up the great work. You are an inspiration to us all.
AWE, I must have looked at this photo for a good 10 minutes. I just couldn't figure out what it was I was looking through. Now it all makes sense! I wish I could have figured it out durrning the challenge. I would have voted higher. (FYI I gave you a 5)
What would I change now that I know what it is? Well, I'm really not sure, there are a few hot spots in the middle of the bubble maybe some PS burning to darken a bit? What if any post processing did you do to your photo?
A little too crazy in my opinion. I dont know how you took this.....through glass? But, I think that you tried a bit too hard. The scenery looks pretty enough as it is without the circle and reflection stuff obscuring it.
I gave this an 8 without hesitation and upon 2nd review, I'm sticking to it. The colors are lovely and the circular quality amidst the angular rocks and logs is really a nice overlayed effect. This would make a great poster!!
I'm not really sure how this fits the challenge. It appears to me that it was shot from inside something like a jar? or bottle. An interesting photo to look at tho. Wow this looks like you move the tripod head almost 360 degrees. Interesting but I bet you get hammered by the voters. I would like to know how this was done. Well done and good luck in this challenge. <9>