Hats off to you for having the guts to submit something out of the box. Sorry it didn't finish higher - I like the image a lot. Very creative and a nice representation.
I can't imagine this photo doing very well in this challenge. The filter apply to the image in post processing eliminates most of the detail that helps most of the voters determine the quality of the photo. Most of the people on this site seem to be photographers first and editors second. Therefore it is my predition that it won't do well. On a positive note... I really like the coloring!
Interesting. I don't think I would have ever entered an image with an embossed treatment. I actually like it, though. I can tell you, I spend more time looking at this than the others in this challenge so far.
You must have applied a filter to this one. It was creative, but I really didn't like the final result. Could you have left one item in the image without the affect and still meet the advanced editing guidelines?
Very unique shot. VERY photoshopped look though...this is my only complaint....you turned a "photograph" into something else...I think this will probably hurt your score in this challenge....not to say that it isn't cool. 7
personally i like the idea. i think you should have stopped at just making a negative of the original, which i still believe conveys the feeling and keeps it a bit more real and related back to photography. this filter is a bit over the top for this site.