Now I am totally crazy. Took this shot while doing the weekly grocery stopping (anything to get a shot). Took in color because my camera doesn't do good bw, and converted.
Statistics
Place: 143 out of 153 Avg (all users): 4.1660 Avg (commenters): 4.2000 Avg (participants): 4.0991 Avg (non-participants): 4.2258 Views since voting: 1261 Votes: 235 Comments: 15 Favorites: 0
This is a subject that really isn't helped by being black and white. That coca-cola bottle is really known for its red and you are subdueing it. Did you just take this at a supermarket? I think this could be a good picture in color and with a little better setup. For example, get rid of the $3 coupons, and the plastic holders.
This is one I think I would have ignored the true highlights on and would have let them burn out a little further and go for the whites on the coke bottles as my base highlight. The angle on the bottles is a nice touch, adds a little interest to the shot.
Seems uninspired and pretty snap shotty. It looks like you're going for symmetry here... maybe turn the bottles so all the labels are facing the same way or get a different angle to show more coke bottles.
This image is lacking the contrast and excitement that the color version would have offered, so I don't feel you've used black & white to the advantage of the photo. If it had to be black and white, I'd probably push the lighter levels further towards light to increase the impact of the photo. It might also have been interesting to play with other focal points -- did you?
fun composition!! what makes it fun is that I can't tell if this is in a store or on an assembly line.. and I like the idea that I am looking into a bottling plant. fun!!