I gave this shot a pretty good rating because I like y our choice of black and white and the light sepia/yellow tone. It's perfect for the shot. This would be a much stronger photo without the border (the wide sides are a distraction for me) and the really blown out highlights in the background.
The foreground is well shot - the background seems a tad too bright. Maybe crop down to right above his hat. Still a good use of sepia. Great urban shot. 7
The border is kind of distracting because it isn't symmetrical with the photo, but I really like the photo! Hopefully that border won't hurt you too much - 7 from me!