Author Thread
Post actions
This has got to be my favorite photo of yours. The coloring is excellent. The exposure perfect IMHO. Nice work.
Post actions
That wouldnt be the Clifton Park Volunteer Fire Department would it? Great shot.. love the placement, framing and tones..
Post actions
Great image. Didn't get a chance to vote this one but I think it is well done. Congrats on your ribbon!
Post actions
Congrats, Neil! Terrific shot!
Post actions
Congratulations on your ribbon, Great Shot!
Post actions
Congrats! This is SO fabulous!!
Post actions
Congrats on your ribbon! Well done.
Post actions
I LOVED this picture!! It was my favorite. I would have liked to see it win blue, but yellow is nice too. Congratulations!!!!
Post actions
Congratulations on the ribbon!!! It was a swell shot. I'm glad to see it did well.
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
Woohoo! Awesome job shapiro
Post actions
Congrats! The ribbons are starting to roll in for you, Neil. Very nice photo.
Post actions
nice ... New York's Capital Region ... Representin'
Post actions
I was almost 100% this would have blued. Very well shot and congrats on the yellow.
Post actions
Congrats! Well deserved! :)
Post actions
Congrats on the third place.
Post actions
Congratulations Neil on your ribbon. Keep em coming!
Post actions
Very nice! Congratulations!
Post actions
Hey congrats - the FP work is starting to pay off ;-)
Post actions
Well done, Neil. Congrats on another ribbon!
Post actions
Congrats on your ribbon, Neil! And Hey....congrats on your POTD at Imaging resource today too!!Message edited by author 2005-08-03 01:16:35.
Post actions
Hey, congratulations, Neil!!!!
Post actions
CONGRATS,....... absolutely brillant photo.. well done..
Post actions
Congratulations on your ribbon. Was one of my top 2 picks!
Post actions
Well you certainly didn't waste any time picking up another ribbon! Congratulations... I thought this one might score OK. ;-)
Post actions
Congratulations on your second ribbon. Well deserved.
Post actions
thats fantastic Neil. Well done :)
Post actions
Congratulations Neil! Well done!
Post actions
Hey Neil: you performed magic here. Congratulations on your YELLOW!
Post actions
Hey, way to go dude! Congrats on ribbon! I'd hoped this one would do well.
Post actions
Very nice - does the job and with simplicity, which is even better. Congratulations on 3rd :)
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
7 - Met the Challenge, barely; In my opinion, the hose is a tool, the only other possible 'reach' I can get is the harness, or the hats, possibly the uniforms but getting into semantics there so in my books 'ok pass' (but it's too much of a reach). I have a feeling this will either win or rate very high. It is a 'nicely composed' photo and the b/w or sepia? works well. Criticism; I would like to see more contrast on the spray and even more definition in the fireys. May be a little 'blown out', not sure on that. Although I mentioned the b/w, given the minimal subjects I wonder how this would have looked in color.
Post actions
Bumping up the second time around. This is a great pic, and is now in my top 2.
Post actions
Very nice coloration, and I very much like the position of the subjects in the frame. Good, concise composition. Like the slope of the hill they're on, and the curve of the hose. Nice job.
Post actions
super job....great tone.....rule of threes superbly adhered to.
Post actions
What a great shot.
Post actions
Post actions
Relevance to theme – 1/3
Post actions
Good capture and setup. The sepia tone is interesting.
Post actions
Post actions
Reminiscent of many of the 911 images. Well done. 8
Post actions
I really like the composition of this. I can see a bit of white fringe around the fireman though-perhaps from unsharp mask?
Post actions
I like the subject of your photo. I'm not so crazy though about the color tone you used.
Post actions
I like this a lot well done
Post actions
Very nice. The sepia filter works well here. The angle of the shot is interesting and makes for a great composition. Maybe the figures are a touch too dark but overll - well done.
Post actions
Post actions
NIce, did you start the fire?
Post actions
Post actions
Oh Wow! I love this one. This one has to be one of the top. . .maybe top 3. I hope so. 10
Post actions
Post actions
Great shot, little hot in the upper left but other than that just wonderful!
Post actions
if you were opposite, the hose tool will have shown better :)
Post actions
Whoa. Would be my choice for number one.
Lifeline
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
