This is exactly the kind of photo I envisioned I wanted to do when I first learned of this challenge. I didn't have an opportunity so I didn't enter :)
You've found a great subject and the lighting is quite dramatic. Your choice of toning is good. I may have cropped out the portion to the left of the house to focus more on the house and cross. Good job!
Nice, good choice to make this sepia toned and I like the composition and the fact that it tilts down to the right. However, I don´t think it´s sharp enough, did something happen when you downsized it or is it just out of focus or did you forget to sharpen it after resizing it?
Beautiful lighting. I love the sepia tone, the composition,the character that shows in the old building, everything. If I could vote, I'd give you a 10. Great shot!
This is a beautiful image. Better post processing would have gotten it a 10 from me. It feels a little middy, a little not-quite-on. Still, a high score from me.
Excellent use of sepia. I love everything about this shot. It is elegant in it's simplicity. Perfect angle to the capture. Really awesome. I'm giving this a perfect score. It is well deserved.
I suspect someone will complain about the angle, but I like it. I like your choice of colorization, as well. I do think the image could use a bit more sharpening all around, but it's not a huge detractor. I vote 7.