this has been done too many times and i dont even think its done that well here. focus seems off and theres not really a composition here to me. its all just smack in the middle which doesnt seem like this works for me.
I would have thought this was a very original idea, if I hadn't already seen it on this site. Try to be more originial in a staged shot like this. It just doesn't convey the same message as used in the other challenge.
This is simple and the centered circle works in this instance. I like the heart it creates on the page. Nice and uncomplicated capture. I might try to figure out a way to rid it of the yellow of the bright light at the top of the page since it's a tad harsh.
OK, this isnt very original since it was only recently done by someone in DPC. but for this photo alone, i'll have to comment that the cropping is a bit poor...the lense got cropped off at the top, and too little space at the bottom too...