Composition: A good simple setup without distractions. Nothing spectacular but it concentrates on the glasses to show the refraction.
Lighting: I think there is a bit too much contrast. The paper is full white and the border of the glasses is pitch black. I think a bit more nuances in lighting would improve the photo.
Focus: The DOF is very wide. The letters in the background are still pretty sharp. Did you try a more narrow DOF? I think that would look better, but that's personal preference. I can see some strange pixels among the letters in the shade of the glasses. I don't know if ot comes from oversharpening in postprocessing but it looks like that. Also did you use some kind of despecle filter? I would expect more detail in the sheets of paper (at the botom of the photo).
Challenge: Yes, challenge met. You actually show an attribute of glass. I like that more than some of the other photos which seem to contain a glass object for the challenge but the photo is not really about the glass.
Creativity: I think the photo lacks drama. It's not a bad shot but I miss something which makes it special. Maybe a ring with a fine engraving in a dark language could have helped ;-)
Ah Lord of the Rings!!! That's an extra point just for the choice of book you used :-)) I like your set up and the effect through the glasses works very well.
Very nice and clear image. I like the angle from which you took the picture, and the way that the glasses lay over the words. This adds nice interest to the pic.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
