This was a hard challenge for me. This photo isn't exactly what I was going for. Then I worked on a different idea for a couple days and couldn't get what I wanted with it either.
I still like this one, and I got a decent shot of my dog doing what he loves most.
Statistics
Place: 57 out of 545 Avg (all users): 5.7682 Avg (commenters): 7.5833 Avg (participants): 5.5482 Avg (non-participants): 6.0650 Views since voting: 1236 Views during voting: 380 Votes: 289 Comments: 32 Favorites: 3 (view)
1. Yes... he did catch it!
2. I had two photo sessions of about 15-20 tosses each. I took 5-6 shots of each toss. I have a lot of outtakes that show frisbee and grass, dog and grass, and just grass. I got nothing useful out of the second session. the shots were set up by tossing the frisbee near the bottom of an 8' ladder with the camera aimed as close to straight down as possible -- I was trying to get a nice circle from the frisbee rather than an oval.
3. The photo wasn't edited -- levels, saturation, curves, USM. I spent a lot of time trying to un-blow the blown white areas. When the dog is jet-black with bright white highlights -- not to mention the white frisbee, it's kinda tricky.
4. I didn't give him a bone for catching it -- I gave him another toss instead (which he appreciates more than a bone anyway! He pretty much lives to play frisbee)
Regarding the frisbee not being stopped -- I actually experimented with shutter speeds to try and get a little spin-motion of the printing on the frisbee. So the fact that the frisbee is not stopped clearly was an "artistic choice" on my part. I appreciate the comment, but I'm happy with the motion there.
Great action shoot - movement is well caught and the placement of the dog and the frisbie are well done. Color could be a bit better but the range a light between the dog and the frisbie was a bit much to get the full effect. Might have been better with a darker frisbie so you didn't have to deal with that.
This is a photo I think could benefit from a wider angle. It's nice to see the detail in the fur and whiskers, but the action could be better portrayed by pulling back a little and showing us the whole dog.
Awwwwwww. . . what a cute subject! I really like how you have kept the dog and the frisbee in focus. Nice composition and great stop action!!! I love this one.