Not that the ribbon winners deserved their wins this week, but I think this one should have been up there as well. I was very disappointed at not seeing it there. ...And I noticed that I wasn't the only one that picked this one as a favorite. Congrats on such a good photograph.
Lovely capture of the sunset on the water. Cropped a bit too close on the left, but otherwise a very moody, very well composed shot. Great stuff, well done. 10
This is my favorite shot for this challenge. You know it's good when you say I wish I thought of that. There is nothing I can suggest to improve this shot. Great work.
I like it! The orange-ish tones of the water make it come alive and the boat being stripped down to a sceleton gives you a sense of history here. Good job - 7
The colors in the water are some very nice hues. I really like this idea and actually I think the crop works pretty well for this picture. I'm usually picky about cutting stuff off but I like this one cut off. I never would've thought to do it this way. Nice job
I love simple photos like this where your mind can wonder anyplace it likes. You did a nice job of making this abstract. It took me a second or two for my mind to put it together and realize what it was. An interesting image with nice complentary colors.
You almost can't tell that this was actually a boat at one time, however, it definately is. This has got to be the winner for the week. The lighting is excellent...I love the colors and reflections of the beautiful water. Then, in contrast, is the ugliness of the boat or what is left of it. You show great detail of the peeling paint and the moss collecting on the surfaces of the portion in the water. I like the angle at which it was shot, with the back portion of the boat trailing off into the shadows. Very clean and well framed. What more can I say, but WOW 10+ My favorite for this challenge.
Nice shot, I would have liked to see more of the boat that is under the water, or a brighter relection on the water surface, either would have worked well I believe.. 9
This is my top favourite for the whole challenge. The texture and the light on the water has such a soft feel to it. The composition couldn't be any better in my opinion and the darkness gives this image a kind of surreal effect. I hope this get's a ribbon, I'm sure crossing my fingers for you!