Positive: Very artistic. Great color saturation.
Negative: When I look at it my focus slips around the picture and eventually slides right off. Every aspect of the compostion leads to the edge of the page. Even the inner part of the barrel is hard to keep focused on. I hope you see what I mean...
9
This is a cool concept. I like the overall effect. I think the presentation could be a lot stronger if the framing did not cut off the reflection of the barrel.
Now that's a shot I've never seen before. High points for creativity and technical skill. Love the color and focus on the smoke inside barrel. Also like how you cropped off part of the reflection. Obviously put a lot of thought into this image.