Author Thread
Post actions
Shame about the DQ. Excellent image and entry...
Post actions
Sorry !! You nailed this one ..... keep it up!!
Post actions
OH I just found out this got DQ'd. Thats a real bummer.
Post actions
Im so bummed this was DQ'd! either way, very nice image!
Post actions
Post actions
This picture says it all, great taste and tribute to our past.
Post actions
This was my favorite..simple shot, lovely low lighting and lots of sky..wonderful effective picture. congratulations!
Post actions
congrats on the well deserved ribbon...it is a beauty of a photo
Post actions
This was my pick to win, but 3rd ain't bad! CONGRATS!
Post actions
Congrats! I just knew this photo would place very well. Outstanding!!
Post actions
Congrats!! Almost too much sky but who cares at this winning point. The colors and subject - perfect!
Post actions
CONGRATS.... i love this shot... i had to look twice to see if it was not a paiinting.... well done...
Post actions
Congratulations on a well deserved ribbon!
Post actions
love the composition, the sky is a highlight ! Congrats on your ribbon !
Post actions
Congrats on first ribbon. I'm really happy to see this one do so well. One of my top choices.
Post actions
HOOray for this one! CONGRATS Robert! You met your goal relatively quick with a fantastic, well-deserving ribbon.
Post actions
Congratulations on your Yellow with this breathtaking composition.
Post actions
AWESOME, rlinn3! TRULY BRILLIANT CAPTURE!
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
I like this shot. I really like how there's so much sky, but I think there may be a tiny bit too much.
Post actions
This is my favorite shot of the challenge and sadly; your title is all too true. I hope you do well.
Post actions
Post actions
hate the title. Too forced. Love the image. 9. Return visit...Still don't like the title. I guess I have negative connotations with the word obsolete. Still love the image. I don't think there is any way to improve it. Bump to 10...
Post actions
Just beautiful! definetly obsolete unfortunatley. 8
Post actions
Very nice composition, great colours, impressive sky.
Post actions
One of the few I've seen this challenge that I really like. Good grasp of challenge theme, great lighting, love the composition. I hope you ribbon!
Post actions
Post actions
I do not agree with the title, but that's not what matters. The photo is beautifull and taken by he that is not afraid if threatening skies. Rated 8.
Post actions
nice shot I would have cropped a little more of the sky out.
Post actions
Stunning. Great colours and light. Having most of the frame filled by sky works well here I think.
Post actions
This is a lovely photo. Dramatic sky. Nice lighting. Wonderful composition. Nicely leveled. It is indeed evocative of an obsolete way of life. And it reinforces my desire to go exploring. My top pick for the challenge. Thanks, and well done.
Post actions
simply fantastic. bumping up
Post actions
magical. The great height of sky against the highlighted teepees is wonderful. A little fuzzy, but still a very strong composition. I imagine it as a fantastic painting circa Remington. Nice job!
Post actions
Wow, what a powerful image. I know that it may suffer from the challenge topic ambiguity, but I'd really like to see it in top 10. And the horizon is perfectly OK, it does not need straightening.
Post actions
to me this is such a wonderful depiction of the challenge very well done.the composition is both intriguing and intense....you get my 10 for this shot
Post actions
Post actions
I think this is a great shot I gave you a 7. This is a personal pet peave but you do not need to use the word obsolete in your title - we all know what the challenge entails. If this wasn't such a good photo I would have given you a lower score based solely on the title. Good luck with this one - I do like it a lot.
Post actions
Awesome! Best one I have seen so far, by far.
Post actions
Minimalist, yet striking image..I like the hard light on tents and the predominance of sky.
Post actions
Well this gets the high mark from me, not a 10 because I think its a tad dark and needs some zest, but compostitionally I think its a winner
Post actions
too much sky...I'd crop it a little on top....but otherwise, it's awesome!
Post actions
Beautiful job. Very nice. In my humble opinion, this should be the clear winner of the blue ribbon. I've reviewed all of the entries (twice now) and found yours to be the most relevant and unique. 10
Post actions
Definately the best I have seen in this challenge up to now. Top Marks
Post actions
A lovely photo just the way it is, but I bet your score could have been significantly higher if you had increased the contrast of the clouds (possible within basic rules by adjusting curves) and straightened the horizon.
Post actions
Wow! I love this shot! Very obsolete and very pretty!!!
Post actions
great Great sky! I really like the comp and everything about this! Tones, lighting, etc
Post actions
great view of the openness of the plain.
Post actions
Lots of sky in this picture. Photo may have benifited with some aggresive cropping. Good composition and color balance.
Post actions
Post actions
woah where did u find these cool tps?? nice colors!
Post actions
The sky looks amazing, but I think you should have taken the tents closer
Post actions
the light is wonderful! Great use of negative space.
Post actions
I really enjoy Native American Art and History, so I really like this shot. There seems to be something in the distance that throws it off a little, but I am just being picky. I really like the white of the Teepees contrasted to the dark sky. I wonder if the shot was taken from the left a little more could you get rid of some of the shadows?
Post actions
This is such a neat picture! I love the angle! Very nice!
Post actions
Post actions
The dark stom clouds really add to the mood.
Post actions
Very touching and thought provoking image. everything came together.
Post actions
Interesting shot, but I think you included just a tad too much sky. There also seems to be a lot of grain the farther we go up into the image.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
