Base Score 5
Good color +1
Composition off -1
Good Processing +1
Total Score 6
Nice photo...I'm not a big fan of the centering of the sunset itself in this composition...I would have cropped it to put the sunset in a lower third target location...Nice lines with the sunset reflection and the dead trees...
Fun idea. The trees definitely wouldn't have been under water in their prime, so that's effective, but, the lack of buildings makes this kind of hard to visualize as Atlantis. Still, there is a mood that sort of works. Beautiful photo.
Beautiful gradiant in the sunset. I just wish that it tied more closely to the theme. If I go with your title of Atlantis, to make it fit in, I can't imagine there being a shore with trees that close to the remnants of a destroyed civilization. But I'll give the benefit of the doubt. 6