nice sky colors and composition, i like the sihlouette shape of the plane. you'll prob be getting hammered by the voters for it not being a real bird but nice photo nontheless.
You must have been thinking outside of the box on this from the caption. Actually I gave you some credit for not interpreting the challange like the other 200+ people.
The image is excellent IMO, but I truely would not consider that to be a bird.
So you are comlpetely not answering the chalenge.
i give you a 6 for a real good photo though. Good luck!
I looked very hard, but I didn't find a real bird, so I assume that the plane is the "bird"
the image is overexposed, colors are weird, oversharpened, composition is to centered, the only good thing is that the plane isn't horizontal. sorry for the harsh comment, but it's just my opinion.
I never give out 1 unless I explain why. First of all, this is way off topic and I have never given a shot I percieve to be off topic a higher grade than 4. secondly this isn´t anything spectacular, it´s just a so so shot of a silhouette of an airplane. The sky isn´t very interesting, the composition is dead centered and well frankly if this were an airplane challenge I would have given it a 3 or a 4. I just don´t find this interesting at all.
Sorry for the rant, but I figured you deserved an explanation as to why I gave it a 1.