Author Thread
Post actions
I remember this very well from the challenge - thought it was great then too. My only minor complaint is that the horizon is horizontal (it's off just a tad) and given the composition and artistic nature, I think it should be. Just my opinion, but the image stands strong as is (I scored it an 8).
Post actions
Very interesting perspective. Great eye and very well captured!
Post actions
Good job on the Top 20 finish. Although, I feel this is Top 3 material.
Post actions
14th!!! I knew this would do well for you! Congrats!
Post actions
Wow, this is fantastic. Leaps out at you. Would have perhaps benefitted from a slightly looser crop at the bottom but I'm assuming there's a reason it had to be cropped that tight. Good job.
Post actions
The frame is so perfectly graphical it looks like it was drawn! That's pretty incredible. Congratulations on a well deserved top 20 finish.
Post actions
JPR, an amazing entry and one that caught my attention. Congratulations on your top 20 finish.
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
The image lacks a bit of luster but the composition in whole is very appealing. Bumping up.
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
Your frame really adds to the impact of the shot..well done!
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
I like the fact that you did not take this picture straight through the middle. It adds creativity and interest. Good shot.
Post actions
Well framed, great color contrast.
Post actions
beutiful frame...
Post actions
Post actions
Absolutely superb. I applaud you for having the vision to "see" this shot and then get it as you did. Wonderful.
Post actions
I only wish the boat was larger...10 though since it is quite unique. Good eye!
Post actions
Nicely pure feeling to it
Post actions
This is a very cool image. Stands out in the challenge. Good Luck!!! 8 and I'm sure I'll be bumping it up in my second go round
Post actions
A superior effort here. Everything fits so clean and concisely. 9
Post actions
Post actions
Great framing and beautiful image. Good luck!
Post actions
Beautiful framing, very nice colors.
Post actions
Excellent "frame: and composition I think.
Post actions
Really cool shot, but the crop is a little tight for me - the bottome edge of the circle is barely cut off, but it's enough to stick out & annoy.
Post actions
Interesting shot. Altho the curvse and circles do very litle for my tastes I find the photo to fit the challenge really well and puts a natural abstract feeling to the photo which in my opinion raises the bar for this challenge. I like the colors, clarity and focus involved with this photo and think it wil do very well dispite me not liking the photo itself. Again just my taste and is a very well thought out and well planned photo. Well done and good luck in this challenge. <9>
Post actions
Love the frame and colour but I feel a more interesting subject within would have been better suited.
Post actions
Ouch! You cropped the circle! Still like the picture though!
Post actions
Very, very nice perspective through the double circles. Nice shadows. Excellent execution.
Post actions
wow would be a perfect ten to me if it was cropped a little better... bottom of circle is cut off, top of circle is closer to edge then the sides... ok im too picky. 10 damnit
Post actions
I love this shot....the color screams "Please give me a high score"...LOL....Nice photo...very sharp
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
