Ooh... a real decision! (and it's naturally framed, to boot) A good idea for a tough challenge, and the unusual point of view is refreshing- you should be proud.. You need some color or dramatic lighting in there for a better score, and more depth of field to emphasize the other earring as the alternate choice.
Very creatively set up shot, I like this. Only problem is that nothing really seems to be in foces, except maybe her shoulder, which isn't a key element of the picture. Nice natural framing.
I am not considering the titles in this challenge.
Artistic.......5
Technical.....5 image seems a bit out of focus, this maybe a depth of field problem due to not having enough lighting on your subject.
Meets challenge description......5
i like how you are able to see the two choices. great idea using a mirror to show this. makes the photo interesting, and keeps the eye moving. good muscle tone as well.
Beautiful soft image. I love that the frame of the mirror also frames the photo. And of course it's very eye catching that the reflection is wearing a different earring than the side of her head visible to the right. Nice example of a decision being made.