haven't read your title, all the action seems to instinct. Technical seems to be good and rates a 5 as does the artistic. I just don't think this image meets the challenge description.
Would have liked to see less foreground (ground) and not have the tips of the horns cut off - but I realize with a great animal action shot you have to take it or lose the entire event/action.9
I don't feel that the image conveys instantly recognizable decision. I love the photo, the title helps too much, I think the decision should be conveyed in the photo. I suppose we have to incorporate a title into some photos simply because we are not all familiar with the subject matter. Good show.
this is an incredible image, although it has little to do with the challenge, im sorry. Only because it needs to be explained to the viewer (I kind of still dont get it, I'll check back when I can read your comment)
I feel like the decision should be clear without having to read this title. In this case, it isn't, so even though it's a nice picture in its own right, I don't think it meets the challenge well...