How on earth did you do this? Did you get someone to jump in and capture them jumping in a standing position just as they were hitting the water? HOW?! Very impressive, although I'm not sure if it fits the challenge. Sink or stand isn't really a decision, standing isn't usually a viable alternative but then again that's what makes this shot so fantastic... I can't bear to vote this down for DNMC... 8
I don't feel that the image conveys instantly recognizable decision. I'd say because of the shot (he's already in the process of sinking, you just caught him before he was in to far (splashes around his feet...)), the title hurt it. Nice pic though, I always like capturing motion.
A great illusion and potentially an allusion (walking on water is a challenge of faith and for many a decision point). That said, alone this image does not tell me a story of a decision. It is to me more a triumph of light and shadow to illustrate an illusion or perhaps only an image of a young man standing on a rock just below the surface. Well shot, it has little interest factor after identifying the pedistal he stands on. I can only offer a 4 compared to other challenge entries.