Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Black and white is the right choice for this. Good that you didn't center this. 8
Post actions
Awesome concept, great composition, well photographed. good luck in the challenge!
Post actions
We have NECCO Wafers out here in California, but I've never seen these...
Post actions
Nice picture....but cannot tell whether these are candies.....
Post actions
B/W works well. I like this composition with the jacks, too. Seems to lose focus as it goes back. Still, nice work!
Post actions
Nice set up, extremely good focus. I sort of question the black and white, but the title explains that pretty well (color just appeals to me more strongly). Constrast levels seem pretty good. Cropping - can't argue with that either. I'm going to raise your score from 7 to 8. It's too well done for a 7 and my bias shouldn't hurt your overall score. Rob the Swash
Post actions
Great take on the challenge, and an excellent shot (focus, lighting, etc>)
Post actions
I love these things. Hard to find around here, though.
Post actions
Excellent use of b/w to tie the whole theme together.
Post actions
nice shot. im too young to recognize this type of candy. and its been a long time since i played jacks, but remeber them. good shot.
Post actions
Nice use of black and white. Good to see someone enter something with the old time candies. Jacks and ball add a lot to the "story" here, too.
Post actions
Post actions
very nice composition... i would have gone with subdued color or sepia if you wanted to convey a sense of 'old'... nice work :) - setzler
Post actions
I loved and love MaryJanes.........yum. Great composition and focus. Nice going.
Post actions
I think this is the most original photograph of all. I love your combination of old time goodies. I think the choice of b&w is a big plus too. I give it a nine! It could be just a tiny bit more in focus.
Post actions
I like this nastaliga but would have liked it better in color, but admit I'm not a fan of B&W"S..Nice job though
Post actions
The use of B&W, the old-fashioned brand (who doesn't remember Necco?) and the toys work well together. You've achieved the goal of drawing on our memories..
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
